This email forward is related to one of the 7 wonders of the world, namely, Taj Mahal, located in Agra, India. As per Purushottam Nagesh Oak, more commonly known as P. N. Oak, an Indian writer cum historian, the Taj Mahal was once a Shiv temple. In his book titled Taj Mahal: The True Story, it is claimed that Taj Mahal was a Shiva temple named Tejo Mahalaya, that was later on taken over by Shah Jahan and converted into a tomb. Following are the arguments given in favor of this claim:
1. The Name
The word ‘Mahal’ refers to a palace and not a tomb. In none of the muslim countries around the world from Afghanistan to Algeria is there a building known as “Mahal”. Both the words, ‘Taj’ and’ Mahal’ are of Sanskrit origin.
The popular notion that Taj Mahal derives its name from Mumtaz Mahal, holds no water since firstly her name was Mumtaz-ul-Zamani and not Mumtaj Mahal, and secondly one cannot omit the first three letters “Mum” from a woman’s name to derive the remainder as the name of the building. Also, since the lady’s name was Mumtaz (ending with ‘Z’) the name of the building would have been Taz Mahal, and not Taj (spelled with a ‘J’).
Hindu temples are often built on river banks and sea beaches. The Taj is one such temple built on the bank of the Yamuna River, an ideal location for a Shiva temple.
At the backside of the river bank is a Hindu crematorium, several palaces, Shiva temples and bathings of ancient origin.
3. Temple Style Architecture
- Some of the popular authorities on architecture like E.B. Havell, Mrs. Kenoyer and Sir W.W.Hunter have clearly said on record that Taj Mahal is built in the architectural style of a Hindu temple. According to Havell, the ground plan of the ancient Hindu Chandi Seva Temple in Java is identical with that of the Taj.
- A central dome with cupolas at its four corners is a universal feature of Hindu temples. The four marble pillars at the plinth corners are of the Hindu style. Finial of the Taj Mahal depicts the trident pinnacle over the dome.
- The embossed patterns on the marble exterior of the cenotaph chamber wall are foliage of the conch shell design and the Hindu letter “OM”.
- Above Mumtaz’s cenotaph hangs a chain by which now hangs a lamp. Before capture by Shah Jahan, the chain used to hold a water pitcher from which water used to drip on the Shiva lingam.
- The Taj Mahal has identical entrance arches on all four sides. This is a typical Hindu building style known as Chaturmukhi or four faced.
- The Taj Mahal has a reverberating dome. Such a dome is an absurdity for a tomb which must ensure peace and silence. On the contrary, reverberating domes are a necessity in Hindu temples because they create an ecstatic din, multiplying and magnifying the sound of bells, drums and pipes accompanying the worship of Hindu deities.
- The Taj Mahal dome bears a lotus cap.
- The Taj Mahal entrance faces south. Had the Taj been an Islamic building, it should have faced the west.
- At the south east corner of the Taj is an ancient royal cattle house. Cows attached to the Tejo Mahalaya temple used to be reared there. A cowshed is an incongruity in an Islamic tomb.
- The marble that Shah Jahan used for grafting Koranic lettering in the Taj is of a pale white shade while the rest of the Taj is built of a marble with rich yellow tint. This disparity is proof of the Koranic extracts being a superimposition.
- The Taj is a seven storied building. It comprises four stories including the lone, tall circular hall inside the top, and the lone chamber in the basement. In between are two floors each containing 12 to 15 palatial rooms. Below the marble plinth reaching down to the river at the rear are two more stories in red stone. They may be seen from the river bank. The seventh storey must be below the ground (river) level since every ancient Hindu building had a subterranean storey.
- The entire Taj complex comprises about 400 to 500 rooms. Residential accommodation on such a stupendous scale is unthinkable in a mausoleum.
4. Customs and Tradition
One needs to remove the shoes before climbing the marble platform. This custom originates from pre Shah Jahan times when the Taj was a Shiva Temple. If it were a tomb, shoes need not have to be removed because shoes are a necessity in a cemetery.
There are 12 Jyotirlingas in India. The Tejo Mahalaya or The Taj Mahal seems to be one of them known as Nagnatheshwar since its parapet is girdled with Naga or Cobra. Vishwakarma Vastushastra has a mention of ‘Tej-Linga’ that was consecrated in the Taj Mahal or Tejo Mahalaya.
Agra has been an ancient centre of Shiva worship. Its residents have been, for ages, worshipping at five Shiva shrines especially during the month of Shravan. However, since the last few centuries they had to be content with worshipping at only four prominent Shiva temples viz., Balkeshwar, Prithvinath, Manakameshwar and Rajarajeshwar. They had lost track of the fifth Shiva deity which their forefathers worshipped. Apparently the fifth was Agreshwar Mahadev Nagnatheshwar i.e., The Lord Great God of Agra, consecrated in the Tejo Mahalaya.
5. Documentary Evidence
Shah Jahan’s own court chronicle, the Badshahnama, admits (page 403, vol 1) that a grand mansion of unique splendor, capped with a dome (Imaarat-a-Alishan wa Gumbaze) was taken from the Jaipur Maharaja Jai Singh for Mumtaz’s burial, and the building was known as Raja Man Singh’s palace.
The ex-Maharaja of Jaipur retains in his secret personal `KapadDwara’ collection two orders from Shah Jahan dated Dec 18, 1633 (bearing modern nos. R.176 and 177) requisitioning the Taj building complex. It was such a blatant usurpation that the then ruler of Jaipur was ashamed to make the document public.
Babur himself refers to the Taj in his memoirs as the palace captured by Ibrahim Lodi containing a central octagonal chamber and having pillars on the four sides. All these historical references allude to the Taj 100 years before Shah Jahan.
6. European Visitor’s Accounts
Tavernier, a French jeweler has recorded in his travel memoirs that Shah Jahan purposely buried Mumtaz near the Taz-i-Makan or the ‘Taj building’ where foreigners used to come so that the world may admire.
De Laet, a Dutch official has listed Man Singh’s palace about a mile from Agra fort, as an outstanding building of pre Shah Jahan’s time. Shah Jahan’s court chronicle, the Badshahnama records Mumtaz’s burial in the same Man Singh’s palace.
7. Sanskirt Inscription
A Sanskrit inscription dated 1155 A.D, wrongly termed as the Bateshwar inscription, and preserved on the top floor of the Lucknow museum, refers to the raising of a “crystal white Shiva temple so alluring that Lord Shiva once enshrined in it and decided never to return to Mount Kailash”. The inscription was removed from the Taj Mahal garden on Shah Jahan’s orders. It was originally installed in the Taj garden before being uprooted and cast away at Shah Jahan’s command.
8. Sealed Chambers
Hindu ornaments and symbols were removed from Taj Mahal. There are sealed chambers in Taj Mahal that hold the remnants of the erstwhile Shiva temple, including a Shiva Lingam.
Apparently those doorways originally sealed by Shah Jahan have been since unsealed and again walled up several times. In 1934 a resident of Delhi took a peep inside from an opening in the upper part of the doorway. To his dismay he saw a huge hall inside. It contained many statues huddled around a central beheaded image of Lord Shiva. It could be that, in there, are Sanskrit inscriptions too.
9. Carbon 14 Test
A wooden piece from the riverside doorway of the Taj was subjected to the carbon 14 test by an American Laboratory. It revealed that the door was 300 years older than Shah Jahan.